Chapter 2 · Secret societies

The Illuminati: Four Students, One Professor and a Myth No Edict Could Ban

In October 1786 Bavarian officials cracked open the most secret society in Europe and printed all of its papers. So why, 240 years later, are people still hunting for the Illuminati on a dollar bill?

A desk at night with a candle, a quill, an open notebook, letters sealed with red wax, a brass wheel and a small pyramid
The picture is AI-generated.
When
1 May 1776 to the late 1780s
Where
Ingolstadt, Electorate of Bavaria
Founder
Adam Weishaupt, professor of canon law
How it ended
Bans of 1784–1787, the order’s papers published
Emblem
The owl of Minerva, not an eye in a pyramid

Landshut, 11 October 1786

For two days, 11 and 12 October 1786, officials went through the papers in the house of Franz Xaver von Zwack, a former government councillor, in the Bavarian town of Landshut. It was the find the authorities had waited years for: more than two hundred letters between the head of a secret order and his closest aides, tables of secret signs, a calendar and invented names for cities, statutes, instructions for recruiters and the text of an initiation rite.

A year later the government printed those papers as a book. That made a society that had hidden from all of Europe one of the few secret unions whose inner workings can be read almost in full. It was called the Order of the Illuminati, the “enlightened”. And here is the paradox: the better the documents showed what the order really was, the more luxuriantly the legend grew of what it supposedly became afterwards.

A professor and four students

The order was founded on 1 May 1776 by Adam Weishaupt, a twenty-eight-year-old professor of canon law at the University of Ingolstadt. The Jesuits had raised him, and their school left him with a lasting dislike of clerical control over education. Weishaupt dreamed of a secret union of reasonable men that would quietly “enlighten” students, officials and rulers. There were five members at the start: himself and four students.

At first the union was called the Order of Perfectibilists, “those who perfect themselves”, but the name sounded odd and was changed to Illuminati. Members took pseudonyms from antiquity; Weishaupt himself was Spartacus. A novice climbed through degrees, and every senior member was required to watch his juniors and report on them upward. The emblem was the owl of Minerva.

The real rise began in 1780, when Baron Adolph Knigge, an experienced Freemason and a gifted organiser, joined. He completed the system of degrees and brought in members of Masonic lodges. By the end of 1784 the leaders boasted of two or three thousand men; historians recounting the rosters arrive at noticeably smaller figures. The papers carry the names of the Duke of Saxe-Gotha, Duke Karl August of Saxe-Weimar and the poet Goethe.

Freemasons and Illuminati: what is the difference

People mix them up constantly, and Weishaupt is partly to blame. Freemasonry is a far older brotherhood with its own lodges and rituals. Weishaupt first wanted to join a lodge, but he could not find the money and decided its “mysteries” were childish. He became a Mason only in 1777, a year after founding his order, when he joined the Munich lodge “Theodor of Good Counsel”.

Through Knigge the Illuminati began to recruit inside the lodges and took over Masonic degrees: apprentice, companion, master. But membership of a lodge was not required to join. They were two separate unions, and the Bavarian edict of 2 March 1785 named both and banned both.

The Illuminati sign: what is not on it

When people say “the Illuminati sign”, they usually mean the eye in a triangle above a pyramid on the back of the dollar bill. The real order had no such emblem; its sign was the owl of Minerva. The Eye of Providence and the unfinished pyramid were approved by the US Congress for the Great Seal on 20 June 1782, when the order was still only gathering strength in Germany. And the seal reached the dollar bill only in 1935.

The order died; the myth outlived it

By the end of the 1780s the order had ceased to exist: bans in 1784, 1785 and 1787, house searches, officers and professors dismissed, Weishaupt driven out of Bavaria. But in 1797 a Scottish professor, John Robison, and a French abbé, Augustin Barruel, declared that the order had not died, only gone underground, and had staged the French Revolution. A year later American preachers were already warning their flocks about the order’s “emissaries”, and in 1969 two editors of Playboy began turning crazed reader letters into a satirical novel about a world conspiracy. Its jokes are still mistaken for facts.

The locked materials hold the dossier without cuts: how a system of mutual surveillance worked inside the order, what exactly was found in Landshut, how a sermon in Charlestown on 9 May 1798 carried the fear across the ocean, and what Jefferson wrote about Weishaupt. They also hold the prank that swallowed the world, the real story of the pyramid on the dollar, and a closing table: what is proven here and what is invented.

The open archive

The r/conspiracy archive holds 534 posts about the Illuminati: 174 of them from 2017, against one in 2009. An order shut down by Bavarian edicts in the 1780s came back online more than two centuries later.

posts on r/conspiracy, 2008–2018
534
comments under those posts
34,213
the first post in the archive
27 August 2009
YouTube recommendations of 306 videos
27,559
views of those YouTube videos
206,984,331

Posts on the topic, year by year

  1. 20080
  2. 200919.9 per 1,000 posts of the forum
  3. 2010520.2 per 1,000 posts of the forum
  4. 20111426.2 per 1,000 posts of the forum
  5. 20123933.5 per 1,000 posts of the forum
  6. 20134016.5 per 1,000 posts of the forum
  7. 20143514.9 per 1,000 posts of the forum
  8. 2015369.7 per 1,000 posts of the forum
  9. 20168916.4 per 1,000 posts of the forum
  10. 201717415.4 per 1,000 posts of the forum
  11. 201810113.7 per 1,000 posts of the forum

The busiest months

  • September 2017 · 24 posts
  • October 2017 · 22 posts
  • January 2018 · 21 posts

Counted from research archives: the popular text posts of one English-language forum, a study of YouTube recommendations and lists of conspiracy websites. What came of it is in the dossier.

The archives:r/conspiracy text-post archive, 2008–2018 (reddit-html-archiver)Faddoul, Chaslot, Farid. A longitudinal analysis of YouTube’s promotion of conspiracy videos, 2020Hanley, Kumar, Durumeric. A Golden Age: Conspiracy Theories’ Relationship with Misinformation Outlets, News Media, and the Wider Internet, 2023

Dossier for readers

The dossier

What is inside the locked materials of this chapter:

  1. The professor the Jesuits disliked
  2. Degrees, pseudonyms and Baron Knigge
  3. From ban to house search, 1784–1787
  4. Prophets of the plot: Robison and Barruel
  5. 1798: the fear crosses the ocean
  6. The Discordians: the prank that swallowed the world
  7. The eye and the pyramid: what is really on the dollar
  8. After the order: revivals, pop culture and forgeries
  9. The order whose papers were printed back in 1787
  10. Timeline: 14 dates
  11. Proven and invented: the verdict
  12. What to read next

Checking your reading permission…

Questions

Do the Illuminati exist today?

Weishaupt’s Bavarian order ceased to exist in the 1780s; it was banned in 1784–1787. Later groups that took the name were marginal. There is no evidence that secret Illuminati run the world.

Are Freemasons and the Illuminati the same thing?

No. Freemasonry is an old brotherhood with lodges and rituals; the Illuminati were Weishaupt’s separate order of 1776. It recruited in Masonic lodges and borrowed some degrees, but lodge membership was not required. Bavaria banned both.

What is the Illuminati sign: the eye in a pyramid?

The order’s emblem was the owl of Minerva. The Eye of Providence over an unfinished pyramid belongs to the Great Seal of the United States, approved by Congress on 20 June 1782, and it has been on the dollar since 1935. No link to the order is proven.

Sources

  1. Stauffer, New England and the Bavarian IlluminatiProject Gutenberg / Columbia University Press, 1918
  2. A Bavarian Illuminati PrimerTrevor W. McKeown, Grand Lodge of British Columbia and Yukon
  3. List of the suspected Illuminati papers found in Landshut, 12 October 1786FactGrid, 1786
  4. Jefferson to Bishop James Madison, 31 January 1800 (Sowerby catalogue, vol. III)Thomas Jefferson Monticello, 1800
  5. The Illuminatus Saga stumbles alongRobert Anton Wilson, Prometheus, Libertarian Futurist Society, 1995
  6. The Eye of ProvidenceGreatSeal.com
  7. Henry A. Wallace, Franklin D. Roosevelt and the Great SealGreatSeal.com
  8. Protocols of the Elders of ZionUnited States Holocaust Memorial Museum
  9. IlluminatiThe Encyclopedia of Science Fiction

Contents of the book